Cruising Sag Harbor and the East End of Long Island

Sag Harbor has been welcoming boats since 1899 and it seems no one has run out of reasons to visit this quaint town yet.
Sag Harbor
Early autumn can be a gorgeous time for cruising in Sag Harbor and exploring shops and restaurants in the picturesque town. pgiam/istock

Historic Sag Harbor is a magnet for cruisers making an East End circuit on New York’s Long Island. Located in the Hamptons and south of Shelter Island, this former whaling port is a well-equipped base for cruising the Long Island Sound and Peconic Bay. It has a lively social scene with rich cultural and culinary offerings.

Docks and Anchorages

Officially established in 1899, the Sag Harbor Yacht Club is one of the oldest in the United States. The transient dock offers side-to tie-ups for boats between 20 and 200-plus feet with drafts up to 12 feet. Reservations are recommended. Other options include Waterfront Marina and Sag Harbor Village Marina. All three are within walking distance of Main Street shops and restaurants.

A classic day sail out of Sag Harbor is the Shelter Island Loop, with popular stops at West Neck Harbor, Coecles Harbor and Dering Harbor. Or head toward the Cedar Point Spit and anchor for lunch, or go ashore to explore Cedar Point County Park. For a longer route, head to Greenport, New York, and reserve a slip at Claudio’s, the landmark waterfront restaurant.

Things To Do

A stroll from Long Wharf along picturesque Main Street leads to many of Sag Harbor’s landmarks, including the Custom House, dating to 1789, and Old Whaler’s Church, built in 1844. The Bay Street Theater often features A-list Broadway and Hollywood actors and comedians. The independent Sag Harbor Books is a beloved local shopping institution. The nonprofit Sag Harbor Cinema screens everything from student films to blockbusters and hosts the annual Martin Scorsese Presents: The Sag Harbor Cinema Festival of Preservation. The Sag Harbor Whaling & Historical Museum chronicles the town’s rich maritime heritage.

Eat & Drink

Sagtown Coffee near the marinas can bookend any day, with a cup of joe or tea in the morning and an après menu of wine and small plates in the evening. K Pasa is a popular stop any time of day for its breakfast Sag hash, 10 varieties of tacos and top-shelf margaritas.

The Dock House’s lobster rolls are considered among the best in the East End. Sen is the go-to for sushi. Tutto Il Giorno is a local favorite for Italian. Page Sag Harbor serves modern American bistro fare, such as crabcake eggs Benedict and Long Island duck. Lulu Kitchen & Bar, a Mediterranean wood-fired kitchen, stands out for brunch and happy hour at its stunning bar. Sag Harbor Tavern has earned acclaim for its deviled eggs, which can be topped with caviar, and its dry-aged burger. The Bell & Anchor is known for upscale seafood, particularly its pan-roasted salmon and bouillabaisse. Reservations open two weeks in advance. Save room and bring cash for a scoop of ice cream at Big Olaf.